Archery Talk Forum banner
1 - 20 of 457 Posts

Scotty C

· Registered
Joined
·
2,481 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
I took a very long hiatus from Archery Talk.
I used to live on this site.
This is my first post in a very long time. And yes I’m choosing to post about Mitch Rompola

A few months ago I joined a fb group called Mitch Rompola fan page.

There were only a few members at first but it gained a lot of followers.
Some were so called internet forensic image analysis taxidermist, critiquing pics from 1998. They don’t last long on the site because all they have is the droopy ear argument. Now, I’m not looking to get into a debate about it here on AT.

What I am here to say is, that fb page has brought so many more bits of info to the forefront.
Much of what is said on Archery Talk isn’t even close to the truth.
•The deer did not burn in a fire.
•Mitchs first critic and biggest opposition was sighted for spotlighting and killing deer. (That’s a fact)
•Lots of info shared by others on the not so legit hunting practices of John Eberhart. (I’ll clarify that it was by other guys that know John not me)
•The actual scorers who haven’t waivered in 25 years.
•A guy at the butcher shop that helped weigh the deer.
•A bus driver who saw it on the hoof.
•The actual truth about the X-ray demands.
•A letter from the CO that was a witness.

If you are a non believer you will show your true colors on here or if you join the site on fb.
If you decide to join the site and can’t maintain a mature adult debate you will be banned rather quickly.
I for one have always been a believer.
Do i know 100% the buck is legit?
No I do not, but there is way more info out there leaning towards real.
The scorers are members of the FB page and others who witnesses the deer either in the truck or at the butcher shop.
A new outdoor life article was written and is on the page as well.

I didn’t post this to really argue about the bucks legitimacy but to rather let believers know there is a great page on FB to find out many answers about the Deer and the Hunter.
Go check it out and keep the comments civil if you can. It’s very interesting to say the least.
 
Discussion starter · #6 ·
Fancy membership drive, but ok
Not a membership drive. Just posting something where I found out way more from people that actually handled the deer and witnessed it.
check it out or don’t.
it’s that simple.
 
Not a membership drive. Just posting something where I found out way more from people that actually handled the deer and witnessed it.
check it out or don’t.
it’s that simple.
I remember your handle, welcome back. Just showing some AT love
 
Damn just when I thought the entire matter was settled along comes Scott C. with this INSANE info dump of NEVER BEFORE SEEN/HEARD bullet points that COMPLETELY UPSET previously conceived TRUTHS regarding the worlds MOST FAMOUS buck! I'll have to rethink my entire position on the mythological 'Rompola Buck' and question the very nature of the universe!
 
Sometimes you want something to be real so badly you trick your own mind into believing it's real. Ask any person who swears they saw Bigfoot lol.
Like 3.5" is 5"...IT'S THE SAME!!!
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Crowbar Jones
Discussion starter · #18 ·
Damn just when I thought the entire matter was settled along comes Scott C. with this INSANE info dump of NEVER BEFORE SEEN/HEARD bullet points that COMPLETELY UPSET previously conceived TRUTHS regarding the worlds MOST FAMOUS buck! I'll have to rethink my entire position on the mythological 'Rompola Buck' and question the very nature of the universe!
Lol! Listen Mr. Eberhart. I didn’t say those things about you, it was someone else. Or is this Craig Calderone?

Of course I’m joking but why so upset?
You aren’t one of those “if I can’t continuously shoot big bucks neither can anyone else” type of guy are you?
Pump the brakes Brotha, it’s not a big deal if you don’t believe.
Your post wreaks of the same narcissism that most doubters convey. But if you haven’t been on the page then maybe there is something you can learn.

I was a high school teacher for 29 years and I love to share new info or other point of views when I find them.
no wonder I stopped visiting this site.

Wait I actually stopped going on this site after the Ohiobooners saga! I didn’t think it could get any better after that lol!
 
Lol! Listen Mr. Eberhart. I didn’t say those things about you, it was someone else. Or is this Craig Calderone?

Of course I’m joking but why so upset?
You aren’t one of those “if I can’t continuously shoot big bucks neither can anyone else” type of guy are you?
Pump the brakes Brotha, it’s not a big deal if you don’t believe.
Your post wreaks of the same narcissism that most doubters convey. But if you haven’t been on the page then maybe there is something you can learn.

I was a high school teacher for 29 years and I love to share new info or other point of views when I find them.
no wonder I stopped visiting this site.

Wait I actually stopped going on this site after the Ohiobooners saga! I didn’t think it could get any better after that lol!
What part about my post appeared even remotely seriously? C'mon 'Brotha'!
 
Damn just when I thought the entire matter was settled along comes Scott C. with this INSANE info dump of NEVER BEFORE SEEN/HEARD bullet points that COMPLETELY UPSET previously conceived TRUTHS regarding the worlds MOST FAMOUS buck! I'll have to rethink my entire position on the mythological 'Rompola Buck' and question the very nature of the universe!
Show us on the doll where Rompola touched you...gonna have to let it go...accept Scotty C's truths...Yes Mitch got a beard trim that day..FACT!
 
1 - 20 of 457 Posts