Great topic...and I guess I like it because it's one that I've NEVER lost my side of the debate on...leastways not in my mind...and while there are minds I've changed and those I haven't?...and while I'm not a fan of the dainty "smaller is better" prim and proper target style armguards?...I wouldn't be caught dead shooting any bow without an extremely substantial armguard such as my current favorite here...
and I wear this no matter what bow I'm shooting whether I'm shooting hunting weight bows or even my 26# form/target rig.
Okay...now explain myself...as follows...
All too often I hear fellow archers proclaim with a near braggart tone to their voice that they never wear an armguard because they are just so good that they NEVER sting their arm with the string to which I say..."Well Bully For You"...but...I don't wear an armguard because I fear the miniscule pain of string sting from a stick bow...or the oft common wrist slap of a low braced longbow...I wear a substantial armguard because I've seen the results of a carbon shaft splintering it's way through a friends forearm...as I was standing but a few feet away when he loosed the string of his 54# recurve and his beman went bang and drove the tail 1/2 of the shaft through his forearm (nearly up to the fletchings) where his forearm looked like someone shot a blowcan of red spraypaint with a .22 rifle.
The groan of pain that came out of him made my butthole cinch up...somebody picked his bow up off the ground...myself and someone else escorted him at his sides off the active back range while a third guy was hopping along frantically removing one of his shoelaces to fashion a tourniquet which was on by the time we got him to the front range to call 911...(pre-cellphone days)...it was months before he shot again and took years for the CF splinters to "grow out of his arm" and never completely did.
So...I don't wear an armguard because I'm afraid of a string whooping...I wear an armguard because my forearm is allergic to cedar and CF...and one of those pansy looking target armguards ain't gonna cut it...and this is usually where the "Well I Check My Arrows" crowd begins their bantering...to which I say....yeah.....right....because out of thousands of arrows shot at shoots....and despite the millions of "Check Your Arrows" warning stickers they wrap around shafts at the factory each year?...I have yet to fill one hand of folks who I've actually seen "check their arrows" at any shoot I've ever attended...and even if they do?...who's to say they didn't miss one?...a cracked one?
So...to me?...shooting a bow without a substantial armguard is about as smart as riding around on a sportbike with the helmet strapped to the rear seat...I don't ride without a lid...and I don't loose an arrow without an armguard...a real one...cause in my experience?...it's just not a wise thing to do....but folks will do what they will...and that's their choice.
All I got and L8R, Bill. :cool2: