Archery Talk Forum banner

Be careful with the cooler method

12K views 50 replies 41 participants last post by  wisconsinted2  
#1 ·
I’m pretty sure this is 100% user error, so feel free to school me. I screwed up aging a doe on ice in a cooler and I’m now kicking my self so I wanted to share this cautionary example and learn from the experts.

I shot a doe last Friday for the freezer and it’s been in the 50s-60s at night. I normally hang my deer but it’s been pretty warm. The cooler method always intrigued me so I gave it a try.

I used a big cooler and did a base layer of ice, I then layered the meat bone in, and then packed ice on top to the brim. Propped up the end and opened the drain so the meat wouldn’t be sitting in water. The cooler has been holding ice nicely since Friday.

I dug everything out today for final butchering and I find all of my meat has been freezer burnt and has lost th deep red color.

I suppose I should have kept the ice from making contact? This is a bummer because this was going to be a good eating younger doe and now everything is frost bitten.

What should I have done differently and What should I do with this meat?

I’ve got it trimmed up pretty well and there are some nice salvageable pieces but most has been frost bitten and is gray. I was thinking this meat will probably have to be jerky.
 
#31 ·
I cut my deer up next day if I can hang or immediately if I cannot. Take the cuts and wrap tightly and thoroughly in plastic wrap. Batch wrapped cuts into gallon bags and toss in the fridge for 7-14 days. Take em out, vacuum seal everything and good to go. I trim everything clean before I wrap it in plastic and toss in the fridge, and have had zero loss since I started doing it this way.
 
#33 ·
I've done the ice/cooler method on the last few deer I've shot. Like others said, the discolored meat is fine. I usually trim it off and put it in the burger pile.

That said, I'm keeping an eye out for a cheap standup fridge or freezer to convert into a meat hanger/cooler. You can purchase a kit that uses a thermometer inside the freezer and cycles the power to keep it at a set temperature so it won't actually freeze the meat.

I'm in south Georgia and even now in November we are only getting lows in the 50s and highs are in the upper 70s and low 80s, so hanging a deer overnight isn't an option here.
 
#35 ·
You can also "wet age" meat in the fridge using ziploc or vacuum seal bags, either before or after freezing. You can cut it up immediately if you like, keep in fridge for 1-3 weeks draining off fluid as needed. Or you can cut it up and freeze it immediately, then thaw and age it in the fridge for 1-3 weeks before cooking it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: roosiebull
#38 · (Edited)
I put the meat in game bags on top of ice. It will lose some color (less than if you covered the whole thing with ice) but it will be fine. The blood from the meat can still drain through the game bags. Which is why I don't get the guys using garbage bags.if the meat was in garbage bags then the blood doesn't drain it just sits in the garbage bags with the meat. That makes no sense. I suppose you could put a baking rack or garbage bag as a "layer" on top of the ice between the game bag to minimize contact between ice and game bag but I don't bother with that. I don't cover all the meat with ice because the ice melts too quick here in Hawaii and the meat can end up towards the bottom of the cooler near the water before I can change it when I'm at work all day.
 
#45 · (Edited)
I stopped using coolers and ice years ago. I don't live far from where I hunt. I use a regulator with one of my chest freezers to cool the gutted and skinned deer down to 36° until I feel like butchering it. Not big enough to hang them, but I'm not trying to age them, either. Either half or quarter the deer so everything fits. Easy peasy.
Image


Eta: got the idea from this guy...
 
#40 ·
The color change is normal. Once you slice it and grind it, the exposure to air will bring back the red color and you won't be able to tell the difference. I prefer to put mine in a fridge I have in the garage and let it cool down and firm up for 3-5 days. However, I do have a big ice chest that I use when I have more than one deer to process. I put down a layer of Ice on the bottom and layer the meat with the shoulders on the bottom, tenderloins, backstraps and boned out ribs and neck, then the hams on the top and cover everything with ice. I open the drain plug and have a clear hose attached to the plug to drain away any melt water. I can fit two deer in the fridge and two in the ice chest (I've done it a few times). I do slice up the backstraps and package them and the tenderloins after 3 days. I bone out the hams and cut up the steaks I want and package them as well if I have time. I usually grind everything else or slice for jerkey on the last day. I do the processing over 3 days so I don't wear myself out.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mossy-Back
#47 · (Edited)
My mom always saves the turkey carcass at Thanksgiving to make soup out of later, and one year when we had the family gathering at our house she just grabbed a trash bag form under the sink and took the carcass home. She invited us all over for soup a couple days later and I could immediately tell there was a nice Febreeze flavor to it. :ROFLMAO:
 
#44 ·
It's not freezer burnt but it's waterlogged and washed out for lack of a better term. It's still fine to eat. Honestly it's not my preferred method but it works.

Next time layer the ice and since a cooler is typically tapered cut some PVC to make a rack just above the ice and place the quarters on it to keep it dry.
 
#48 ·
I don't think you hurt any of the meat. I've compared eating aged venison and non-aged venison and my tastes buds cannot tell the difference. I'm not saying others can't tell the difference, but I can't, so I don't bother aging. I live on venison. When I'm home I eat it for lunch and dinner. Dinner, I'm always grilling it every night in all weather. In fact, I haven't bought beef in 30 years. I've brought meat back from bow hunts all over N. America in a cheap Walmart 5-to-6-day coolers packed in ice for 4 to 5 days and the meat has always tasted great. The key is to never open the cooler until you're ready to butcher. Opening the cooler releases cold frigid air and brings in warm air.