I think they will score about the same 120-125. The top one will score better if the (g3) counts as a g3 and not a non-typical point. I think there is a rule that says if it comes off the g2 or off the main beam and I can't see it well enough to say.
enough :wink: .......good deer...and good luck! Hopefully the next picture we see, his tongue will be hanging and you will be smiling....then we'll know for sure. I wouldn't let him go, unless I was after one that I had seen that was bigger. But you know what greediness can get you.....Tag diner.
Both of those bucks are POPER's for sure. I have a 119 5/8 on the wall, and he's got more mass than either of those, but not near the tine length, and he's only an 8-pt. If you haven't killed your first P&Y buck, either of these will make 125" easily, even with deductions!!! Good Luck!!!
On another note, I'd like to see more of the pic to see what the deer in the background of the second pic is doing.
A forum community dedicated to bow and crossbow owners and archery enthusiasts. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, performance, troubleshooting, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more!