Alright guys I need some consoling. I ended up having a nice 8 pt come in to my food plot this weekend right at last light and I studied him as much as I could and it was obvious that he was an extremely old deer. Huge body, pot belly, Greyish coat, and when I got him I noticed he was missing many teeth. I would guess him at at least a five year old maybe plus. Although, his rack was really pretty weak compared to some other bucks that i believe I have on my land. I just felt as though I was obligated to take this buck out of my herd for management reasons. I have saw on hunting shows this done but I never thought that I would be put in this situation. Now I am a little disapointed in the fact that my season is done because of the one buck limit in Indiana. I feel as though I would have easily had a chance at a better buck had I held off on him. Did I do the right thing?What would some of you guys have done had you been in my shoes?