Archery Talk Forum banner
21 - 39 of 39 Posts
When you backpack for a week or more at a time there is not too much you can do about scent control. Basically, I clean up a bit with unscented wipes, rotate clothing every other day if possible, take a river bath every other day or so, and play the wind.
 
I change clothes religiously every third day. Other than that I don't pay much attention to it. I've cooked in the same clothes, built fires to dry out with or warm up, and sometimes use scented baby wipes because it makes myself more tolerable to myself.

.
Similar here.

Complete control isn't possible. I personally don't think scent control clothing works, and is a waste of money. All things considered, if a little more preparation, and precaution is taken, it just might give you that little edge for just those few necessary seconds.
Cover scents can help too. As mentioned earlier, we never pass up fresh elk pee, and have been known to rub sage and other plants on our clothes.
I just think, the less you give a big old bull to work with the better. He does have a little bit of an advantage.
:thumbs_up:thumbs_up


I used to have my rituals as well as most did in our hunting camps. A good dozen or so years ago I decided to slowly drop a thing here & another there. Slowly I quit doing all the prep & keeping my hunting clothes put away in these odorless compartments & such. These days we do nothing & I mean nothing at all. We hunt the wind religiously, no if & or buts! We kill as many elk today as ever.

Actually I feel it's even better for us on the larger scale. We know we are not odorless so we don't even dream of pushing the envelope & allow the wind to go the wrong direction. We simply will re-maneuver or get out of the area completely, we will not force our scent down their throats.

I'm not saying this is for everyone, but it has made us better hunters knowing full well we have to abide by wind direction at all costs. This is the way it should be for everyone. I feel it's the guys who feel they are scent free that push the envelope because they think they can get away with just a little bit! (grin) No way!
Use what works for you but as for us scent control by man made stuff is not needed by us. We do just fine, don't fix it if it ain't broke! (grin)

ElkNut1
:wink:




Yep they wind ya...they wind ya.....and it won't matter if you smell like roses or sh*t !
.
.
.
.
.
.
 
I agree with beendare. If it one molecule they smell or a thousand then you are busted. I killed my first bull a 6x6 at 3 yds with the wind at my back and no scent control. He just didnt smell me.
 
I agree with beendare. If it one molecule they smell or a thousand then you are busted. I killed my first bull a 6x6 at 3 yds with the wind at my back and no scent control. He just didnt smell me.
do you think that if the elk is on high alert it makes a difference in comparison to an elk thats not on high alert?
 
I change clothes either every other day or whenever I can, but other than that, I try to constantly hunt into the wind. That is the singular best method of "scent control" that I have found over the years

I have a solar shower that we use at base camp every couple days

I used to go crazy with scent control, cover scents, etc., but it just seems like it doesn't matter what you do when the wind swirls, you're just busted!

Best of Luck,
Jeff (AT Sponsor)
www.elkmtngear.com
 
I get into it some but not to the extent of some of you, silver xp, some scent a way clothes wash thats about it. Biggest think as far as scent control for me my wind tester. The guy i hunt with, most of the time, will stop have a smoke let out a cow call and go, we've had elk come to ten feet a couple minutes after he was done with a smoke. I have had way more bust from sound and sight than smell. I should do more for scent control i guess but things have worked out so far.
 
Yep, I hear ya! I used to do lots of the things you mention & more! (grin) Not anymore! (grin) As I mentioned, I'm not trying to sway anyones thoughts I just answered the question & gave the reasons why!

I've answered this question countless times over the years & it never ceases to amaze me how many times guys will come back with statements like---but ya we get really close to the elk or we have elk come through our camp & the elk are always close by because of our scent control. We have elk smelling our packs & so on. I'm not kidding I get this a lot! Guess what guys, we too get close to elk, they run through our camps too. (grin) We have fires every night or nearly so, my clothes smell like campfire half the time & I'm sure a bit of food smell as well, but it hasn't been an issue at all.

Like mentioned above, I used to subscribe to all that stuff too. But since saying to myself it isn't needed we have not seen any difference in anything. I'm not saying don't use any precautions but being anal is not necessary! At least for us it isn't & I'm sure it wouldn't be for you either. Anyway, yes we experience the same close encounters & I've been so close to elk I could count their eyelashes!

I killed a bull one year in a small 3-4 acre mdw where my son & I were just making our way across it, we had only gotten 20yds into it just after light when we spotted movement on the opposite side entering from the timber, there wasn't anything there but 12" of half dead grass there, not a thing to hide behind. We crouched down on one knee & sat motionless. The elk slowly entered the meadow, 7 cows & 2 calves, there was zero wind, pretty much dead calm & the surroundings were flat as a pancake there in the mdw. Several of the cows milled around until they were within 10 yards of both of us, the calves were hopping around & darting like nobodys business having a blast!
5 full minutes went by before we caught movement across the mdw & here came the bull just moseying along & in no hurry. He walked over to the cows & smelled a couple of them & stayed on the other side of them. Every once in a while a cow or two would give us a quick stare, we didn't move & they'd go back to feeding. We were really hoping the wind would hold up & not give us away. Finally the bull moved off to the left of the cows 26yds away & was staring at them. I had an arrow nocked on my longbow & was ready for a split second opportunity.
All of a sudden a bull bugled a good distance away & this bull turned away from us to look in his direction. That gave me the chance I was looking for. I had already told myself if the time came I would draw no matter what the cows were doing & yes they were real close now. He turned, I drew anchored & let the arrow fly taking out both lungs, he was dead in 150yds. Not one cow flinched in my drawing & release motion, but blew out of there when he did.

Now, I guess if I'd been wearing the latest high tech stuff & went through all the rituals I could give credit to that, but I didn't do anything special nor did my son. The credit goes to the wind not hitting us in the back, if it would have it would have given us up no matter what we did to eliminate the human scent. I've killed elk everyear since I stopped making a big deal out of stuff. So I'd hate to be dishonest & lie about what precautions we take, since we do not take any. We simply hunt the wind.

I will also mention that we've killed many bulls the very next day from a 100yds to 300yds away from the day befores carcasses & kill site. I can only go on & relate personal experiences & this has been ours. We hunt the wind exclusively & success is hard to argue with! Keep doing what works for you!

We are not fools either, we don't camp where our scent will drift right into our hunting area where ever that might be. Hunt smart & camp smart & there's no need to be too primitive, camp fires are ones best companion!

ElkNut1
Okay. The guy with 572 bull kills must be right! :wink:

I think I may be a little less anal next year. I guess it will be nice to have a few less things to worry about.

I can tell you right now, I am still not telling my pops what you said. We do have to sleep in the same tent and after a few days in the backcountry he smells brutal! lol
 
Okay. The guy with 572 bull kills must be right! :wink:

I think I may be a little less anal next year. I guess it will be nice to have a few less things to worry about.

I can tell you right now, I am still not telling my pops what you said. We do have to sleep in the same tent and after a few days in the backcountry he smells brutal! lol
Just use the wind. lol. I'm pretty sure that when you think you smell the best, elk would beg a differ.
 
We've tried everything over the years. Never did matter to the elk. So we don't worry about it anymore. If I kill an elk, I've kept the wind in my face. If I don't kill him, he runs off wondering what the hell that sweaty, smokey horse with bacon grease all over him was doing at 9500 feet!
 
I thought I would touch on a subject that hasn't been discussed yet with all the elk threads.
What are your opinions about scent control?
Do you worry about your scent, when it comes to elk?
If so, what preparations, or precautions to you use, and make?
Here are some of the things we do, and don't do.
I for one, believe that scent control is very important, when it comes to elk. I am one of those hunters, that does allot of belly crawling, taking great care, to see how close I can get to my prey. It started with deer and hogs, and progressed to everything I have hunted. It is a huge rush, when you get into an animal's space, without it knowing you are there. It is an extreme challenge, and depending on the animal, and the conditions, can be really difficult.
Elk use there senses to their fullest, combining all of them, even at long distances, but, they really utilize their sense of smell. I have witnessed them winding hunters at long distances, depending on the conditions.
Personal care: We take great care in keeping our scent to a minimum. Our base camp has provisions for hot showers. We use scent free soap, deodorant, and foot powder. We wash in scent eliminating soap. We change and wash our clothes as often as possible, again with scent eliminating, scent free soap. We carry scent wipes,(especially if the weather is warm), and use them often, especially after taking a big dump in the woods. We also never take a big dump near elk beds and other areas they are using.
We spend allot of time out at spike camps as well, but still wash allot, even if it is in a cold stream. We always leave extra clothes at our spike camps, as well. We don't have fires that often, and never wear the clothes that we are hunting in, while cooking, or doing camp activities that could put odors on our clothes. At our base camp, we have a separate cook and eating tent. Our clothes and hunting gear are never kept in the cook tent.
Some may think this is all a little extreme, but, it has proven to make a difference over the years. It depends on how you hunt, and how far you push your encounters with the animals.
We have had guys in camp, that don't consider their odor. They rarely spend much time close to the elk, and wonder why they can't slip in close. You don't always have the wind in your favor, and it can change in a heartbeat. I spent several days one year trying to help an old guy that camps with us hook up with a bull. I called for him, took him to several hot spots, and set him up with quite a few shot scenarios. He always got busted. I finally suggested he clean himself up a bit.(I could smell him whenever he got up wind of me). He got a couple shots after that, and commented on how close he got to the bulls.
Keeping your scent to a minimum is a pain, but, it could make a difference for only a few seconds, and give you an opportunity of a lifetime.
I think you should look into Trophy Blend Scents, we are coming out with a line of Scent free stuff this year.

We finalized the last test on the NEW Trophy Blend Deo Stick "Deoderant" NO Scent at all works great and its NOT white and pasty like some of the others!!! "Totaly Awesome" is what I have been told by the team of testers!!

Also we are currantly working on a Scent Killer spray, bar soap, body wash, and Laundry Soap. ALL scent free. So feel free to check us out at our web site. www.trophyblenddeerscents.com
 
I think you should look into Trophy Blend Scents, we are coming out with a line of Scent free stuff this year.

We finalized the last test on the NEW Trophy Blend Deo Stick "Deoderant" NO Scent at all works great and its NOT white and pasty like some of the others!!! "Totaly Awesome" is what I have been told by the team of testers!!

www.trophyblenddeerscents.com
I really hate it when the wind swirls, and you think "OMG, what is that smell"?

Then, you realize it is YOU :pukey:

I'm gonna give the Trophy Blend Deo stick a try, gotta use something out there!

Best of Luck,
Jeff
 
Honestly your wasting your time with all the scent elimination products. You are not going to fool an elk's nose. You may cover up "some" of your human scent but you are just putting some other "foreign" scent on that an elk is going to pick up on in a heart beat. I have hunted elk for years and years and the best advice is to stay up wind.
 
I do use some scent control tactics, but do not go overboard. Shower and wash clothes with scent free soap, change of clothes every day if I'm on a week long hunt (I do not pack in). Hunt from my camper. Playing the wind is the best scent control. I will never spray elk urine on my clothing, because then you are smellling elk all day, even when your not close to elk. I do however carry a bottle with me that I mist into the air if I am in close and the wind starts swirling.
 
IMO in 90% of situations you either have the wind or you don't. It's really just that simple. Alot of gear companys make millions off the other 10% of the time. I've been busted when the wind shifted and I was wearing all the new fangeld carbon stuff and had sprayed EVERYTHIG down. Then again I've been 10 ft from a cow and I smelled like hell with the wind at my back and she just starred me down, until I tried to draw and she bolted. It's really about the law of averges. Far more times than not if you do not have the wind you will get busted.
 
I still do try to control my scent as much as possible, within reason.

That being said, I do think all of our scent control efforts are like putting a diaper on a skunk. No matter how good that diaper is, we are all still going to smell the skunk. Heck, I can smell a skunk going 75 miles an hour in my car with all of the windows rolled up, while I am eating a cheeseburger, from almost a mile away.

I think that is how elk smell us, pretty much no matter what we do. Watching the wind is rule number one!
 
Imho

IMHO guys your a human.. your gonna smell like a human....All this scent crap is just making someone else a living...Do your self a favor and save your money for the hunting trip you have always wanted to go on...AND JUST HUNT THE WIND THE BEST YOU CAN!!...If the wind blows from you to them..GAME OVER SIMPLE AS THAT!Don't buy this well it helps,They will think your 100 yards away instead of 20??? RIGHT!!! Think that matters to them??? NO. they smell you and that is that....
 
Only scent control I use is the wind.
i agree. Have you ever spent 3 hours climbing strait up the rocky mountains. Everyone stinks to an elk after that. If you dont understand the wind and thermals on the mountains , and use it to your advantage. Then you can forget about killing and elk.
 
21 - 39 of 39 Posts