I've been fletching my own arrows with 3" feathers for about a year now and I just started 3-D shooting this year. I've been to a lot of shoots and only had to re-fletch two arrows and both of those were messed up because I missed. Feathers seem to hold up great for me! I've damaged feathers with other arrows while shooting at my house, but that doesn't happen very often, and it would probably do the same thing to vanes anyway. Just my opinion! -Christhey would probbaly get beat up pretty quick with other arrows hitting them all the time...