Good suggestions above. Here are some thoughts to add to the pot.
Where is your nock set? Generally the nock set has to be above level for a fingers person. Exactly where depends on the draw style (three under, or split), how you grip the bow, and possible even tiller. But generally, guys seem to set the nock anywhere from 1/4" above square all the way up to 5/8". Put a bow square on your serving and rest, and see where you are. Experiment a little and see if it changes. I generally need to be about 3/8".
If your nock set is too low, the arrow can sail upwards.
Hitting left in general can also be a spine match issue. Shooting a bare shaft can help figure it out, but you need someone to help you that understands bare shaft stuff, or it may drive you crazy. Are you seeing any wobble or porpoising in the arrow flight when you step back and shoot? Hitting left for a RH shooter can mean an over spined (too stiff) arrow. I think your arrows are 400 deflection, so they may be fine depending on your head weight and shaft length. If spine is the culprit, you might see some benefit from a heavier point, so you can try a heavier point just to see if that helps.
Are you seeing any excessive feather wear on the inside feather? Or are you shooting vanes?
If you are just getting started good, I would encourage you to at least try three under. Even better, draw three under and drop the ring finger. For me the joints in the fingers line up better with the middle and ring fingers.
Another option is to draw split, and drop or substantially drop the index finger. For some people, depending on your anchor point, a split draw causes you to torque the string.