Archery Talk Forum banner

How dark is too dark to shoot?

5.5K views 40 replies 28 participants last post by  Brettski7  
#1 ·
So I'm sitting on a stool on the ground about 8 yards from a game trail. It's my first time out ever, and I'm learning everything I know now through this forum (Thank you all!) and YouTube videos.

I hear a deer approaching through a field, he emerges and all I can see is a dark figure slowly walking right past me. As he reaches my position, broad side, he stops and raises his head, staring right at me. I can see the outline of his rack in the moonlit horizon, but still too early to see the pins on my sight. I had already decided when he was approaching that I would let him pass in hopes that he comes back when I can see better. This was the buck that passed me:

7299891


He was less than 10 yards away:

7299893


It was 6:00 am. Sunrise was somewhere around 6:50. He circled around a pond that was behind me, I could hear him huffing and puffing once he was down wind from me, and then he bolted. I can't wait to get back out and hopefully have another chance at my first buck. It could be a blessing in disguise because I learned that my real target was around at 2:00am. I believe I saw him in the distance that morning in an area I haven't scouted yet at 7:30am. I love this adventure I'm on.

Here's who I'm really looking for:

7299894

7299896
 
#2 ·
Well, it has to be legal in your state.... So what is it in MD? 30 min before sunrise?

And then you need to be able to see clearly enough to pick the spot on the deer you are aiming for. Not just the outline of the deer - the exact spot to get an ethical quick kill.

Not be rude here, but have you studied where on the deer you need to hit?
 
#3 ·
If I can’t track my arrow and see exactly where it hits then it is too dark! Read the amount of threads where you see the words “I don’t know where it hit”.. How can you possibly decide the best tracking process when you have no idea what you hit? The hunt is just beginning when you squeeze the trigger, every detail after that point is where animals are recovered or lost!
 
#7 ·
If I can’t track my arrow and see exactly where it hits then it is too dark!
That was my thought. The last thing I want is a poorly executed shot. Plus I knew it wasn't legal in MD (30 minutes). I just wondered if even within 30 minutes of "sunrise" on a poor weather day what visibility may be like. I've never sat out waiting for sunrise before, so that was a unique experience for me.
 
#13 ·
MN legal is 30 minutes before sunrise and my pins start to glow at about that same time most mornings. There is generally enough light at that time to see the aiming features on the deer, also, if it is within 20 yards. I don't hunt deep woods, so that would obviously impact when it is light enough.
 
#16 ·
Here’s something to consider. Practice shooting in low light and see how you do. I’ve hunted both before sunrise and past sunset (I live in maryland). Very rarely is legal shooting light good enough for any type of hunting. Sometimes in wide open field and perfect conditions. But if you’re in a tree line, you may have even less time. Even if your pin does glow bright enough in low light, there’s a chance the pin is too bright for the target and your shot won’t be as accurate
 
#19 ·
In Illinois we can shoot a 1/2 hour before actual sunrise and a 1/2 hour after sunset. Those half hours can be tricky some days depending on the sky cast or moon phase. Sometimes it feels like with a full moon you can shoot way before or after that but I’ve never been able to make out my pins or have the ability to even see where the arrow goes.

I wouldn’t recommend pushing those times, even if it can be enticing. My friend had a guy shoot an arrow towards him once walking the field edge back to his truck. Only missed him by a couple feet. That guy was hunting the ground.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
#22 ·
You're doing things right, ...............
No he's not.

He's a complete newb hunting on the East Coast, and you're an older guy that lives in the "wild west", that just started shooting a bow three years ago.
These are two completely different worlds.

He's sitting on a stool 8 yards from the trail. That's not a setup that anybody with experience hunting east of Nebraska would recommend.
 
#23 ·
Here in Ga legal shooting light can be well before you can “see clearly” or well after sundown when you can still legally shoot. In South Carolina it is an hour before and after sunset I believe. My limit is always when 1.) I can identify what I am shooting and 2.) I can still see my pin and the animal through my peep. This can vary and you really have to judge the situation.
 
#32 ·
Too me it sounds like you did everything right. If you can't see your pins you shouldn't shoot. A light will light up the pins but if you shoot a peep you still might have to pass. In many states it's legal to shoot WAY before or after you can see your pins unless they are lighted.
 
#35 · (Edited)
I sometimes turkey hunt from a popup blind where it is significantly darker inside due to blocking ambient light. For that reason I have a sight light and used it a couple times on turkeys that I could plainly see outside the blind but not my pin inside the blind. In the case of low ambient light, just turning on a sight light will make your pin burst but won't change a thing about seeing the animal clearly. That is precisely why the repeated suggestion of practicing in low light conditions is really sound. What I have learned is that my depth perception is altered as light dims.....things look farther away. My sight light has a rheostat and at the lowest setting I can see OK to shoot, but it makes picking a spot on a dark animal like a deer more challenging.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dafis
#37 ·
When it's legal and when you can see your pins and your target. I can see my pins and don't use a peep so I can shoot anytime as long as it's legal (like at night for pigs) or 30 min before or after sunset for deer. Could you even see the racks? Or just an outline of the deer? Or just hear them?
 
#39 · (Edited)
Most states i hunt legal shooting is half hour before sunrise and half hour after sunset. That is pretty generous as it can get difficult to see at sunset, depending on weather conditions and geography. If you are in a deep canyon and it's clowdy, it's nearly impossible to see at sunset, let alone half hour later.

Sent from my SM-G973U using Tapatalk
 
#40 ·
Here in Arkansas, legal hours are 30 minutes before sunrise time until 30 minutes after sunset. Most often, the "to dark to shoot" time is slightly closer to sunrise and sunset for me when hunting in the mountains. If I can't clearly see the kill zone, it's too dark.