[HoytHunter4]

Can't quite tell for sure but I think it is the same buck. The first picture is of him last year in velvet. That is the only picture i got of him last year. This year i got a picture of what looks to be the same buck at my mock scrape. Do you guys think this is the same deer??

 

[crockett]

i would say no!

 

[bowhuntnsteve]

I wished u had more angles. By looking at its right side, I'd almost say yes, but looing at the left side, then I say no. Its either got grande brows or something coming up from the left brow area. Looking at the 2nd pic, the end of the main beams and G3, there is a kicker or something, can't tell on the left beam what it is. But it maybe the same buck with another year of growth on him.

 

[HoytHunter4]

This is a back angle of him from this year but you really cant compare it to his rack last year.

 

[Pickert]

Wow thats a tough one. I would almost say yes, but could be wrong.
Either way nice deer.

 

[King]

Judging from the long brow and tine angles, I'd say it's the same buck. Great genetics on him too. Great tine length.

 

[scrapejuice]

I'd say yes, since those pics are from 2 different years.

 

[Booner1331]

I say yes

 

[silver_yummies]

i'd say yes, since those pics are from 2 different years.

+1

 

[drawemback]

No way...too much going on with that second picture to say that is the same deer.

 

[M.Magis]

I can't even see a small resemblance, let alone enough to make me think it could be the same deer. I don't know what some of you are seeing that I'm not.

 

[msgobblergetter]

Unless he has put on some massive brow tines in the past year, I'd say no. I think this year's deer is a different one. Its very possible, but I put my money on no.

 

[HoytHunter4]

Thanks for the input guys. Anyone else?