I tried both the web 4 and q lite two piece styles and prefer the web, even though I keep it on my bow when shooting. It's almost the same form factor as the two piece and weight just about an ounce more. Also for whatever reason the two piece made some noise when I would draw with arrows loaded, maybe as the rubber shifted when the riser flexed. The foam on the web is very durable from my experience the past couple years using mechanicals.