Archery Talk Forum banner

Meindl Comfort Fit Extremes, NI

4.8K views 6 replies 4 participants last post by  Where's Bruce?  
#1 ·
Okay, this might just be it. Got the new Meindl Comfort Fit Extreme NI boots in today, and just like the guy said over the phone, the 9M’s are made for me. These are interesting boots and I’m quite impressed with the way they are built. I was surprised the 9’s fit me, because normally a 9 is too small since my left foot which is ever so slightly larger than my right is 9.5 on the money on the Brannock measuring device, but obviously the rep knew his product and these boots fit better than any boot I’ve ever put on my foot. They are wider in the toe box, so I have plenty of room for my toes to splay out vs being confined and crunched. I found it funny, but he said to make sure I trimmed my nails on my toes so they would not be an issue. I guess if you are in his position, you have to get used to telling people to remember hygiene and personal maintenance….LOL. But the softer leather beside the tongue folds back like it is supposed to and only the thicker boot leather is directly under the laces, making the boot very solid and provides no pinch points or hard spots which is very nice. The heel is more narrow, so the boot just naturally locks your heel in place which is also very important for those hard, steep uphill climbs. The cork footbed will conform to each person’s foot, so it will feel natural to put your foot into your boot each time. The top of the boot is taller, which I LOVE, but the back of the upper part is a softer but sturdy material that flexes with your movements, and does NOT dig into the back of your calf like so many other boots I’ve had. There are several flex points near the ankle, so the boot has these spots that are softer and flexible in these areas instead of having the more solid leather in that area which is on a lot of other boots, so when you bend your ankle, the heavier leather is compressed and has to go somewhere, and many times this flexes inwards and pushes into your foot causing discomfort. The tread is a Vibram sole, and is called a “Multigriff-Profil” which is German for won’t slip….🤣. The rubber is actually more flexible and “grippy” than any other mountain boots I’ve tried, by a wide margin, but still very supportive overall. Most of the time the sole is so hard on this type of boot, it makes it slip more easily for me, making the boot more of a challenge to traverse rough terrain. When I walk on pavement with these, I can feel the boot gripping the pavement and it will not allow me to twist or spin due to its grip-ability. That I really like. I’ll still fall down once a day or so, but that’s just the way I roll….😆, no way around that….lol. I also love how the hooks and laces are done and designed. The speed hooks start a little lower, so getting these off and on is a breeze, and it allows you to do a surgeon’s knot twice at the flex point which totally locks the boot to your ankle, which keeps your heel locked into the heel pocket. The eyelets in front of these speed hooks have a ball bearing (or something) in the middle of them so your laces slide easily over this ball, keeping the laces from fraying. This allows them to move when they need to move, but not on a sharp edge, extending the life of the laces. Very ingenious. These boots look VERY much like Kenetrek Mountain Extreme NI's, with the larger rubber band that surrounds the boot for protection which I like very much. Anyway, I could go on and on, but so far, just wearing them around the office and around town today, I’m impressed way beyond what I had hoped. I read a lot of the reviews on these boots, and other than a few reviews where the boots did not fit the person’s feet well (which goes for ANY brand) the reviews were almost over-the-top with 5 stars, and so far I can see why. I plan to hike the trail at the end the road later today with my pack (loaded light for boot testing purposes) and just see how I do as I start my break-in on them. I will say, I’ve never felt a boot this comfortable right out of the box, and really have high hopes that these will be the end of my search for a quality boot that will fulfill my needs for hunting places like Colorado etc.

I'll report back later with updates as to how they do during the break in period, and will be taking them to Colorado here in a few short weeks, so I'll try to report back once I'm home on their performance etc. I have tried way too many top shelf boots and I think every one I've gotten in are great boots and very well made, so no bashing the other brands for me. But each person's feet are different and well like different stuff, so one man's boot will not always do for another. But I will say I really do like the build and features thus far, and hope they will continue to impress in the field.

And I bought these after reading some of you guys posts on what boot you prefer for back country hunts. So those who recommended these boots, thanks for sharing.

Image
 
#2 ·
They look virtually identical to the Meindl Perfekt Hunter boot with 400 gram insulation that Cabelas sold for 25 years and I've used all that time. Best fitting boot for me I ever used...narrow but deep heel pocket (no heel blisters) and wider toe box. Bought 3 pair on sale when Cabelas quite handling them around the Bass Pro buyout time. Probably have worn out 3 pairs of them.

I also love the uninsulated 7" Meindl Perfekt Hiker. Virtually the same fit and feel as the taller boot. Have a couple new pair put away from the Cabelas days and have worn out 4 or so pairs.

Glad they are still making a similar boot. Good luck with them!
 
#3 ·
I was the same. I used to buy the Cabela's Meindl Ultralight Hunter boot as they just worked for my foot, but they quit carrying or making them, so my search began after I wore out all the pairs I had bought of them.

Update after my short break-in hike from yesterday evening. I took my daughter with me as she wanted to hike some with me and we set a pace we both were comfortable with and hit the trail. I wore my basically empty Kuiu 6000 pack just to get the feeling of hiking with my pack, plus I have places to hold my water bottles and open carry. The hike was amazing. I did the same hike a week ago with no pack and some other new boots I was trying, and ended up with a small blister on my right heel, which is always the case when my boots just don't fit exactly correct. I re-laced to try to lock my heel down with the other boots, but it just wasn't happening.

With the Meindl CFE's, my heels were locked in great, no slippage on the uphill, and on the downhill, my toes never banged into the toe box on the boot. No hot spots, no rubbing, just locked in and ready for action. Grip on tree roots and rocks was excellent and I felt in control the whole hike with sure footing every set of the way. Excellent ankle support, and I loved how they laced tight to my lower leg. I did have my Darn Tough tactical boot socks on, so they provided the perfect amount of cushion and helped with keeping my feet from feeling wet from sweat.

So for me I feel my boot journey has reached it's end, which is wonderful as it's been a long hard journey, especially when your feet are in constant pain. Totally impressed with these boots and the customer service I received when placing my order. Now to continue my break-in and be ready to hit the Colorado trails here in a few short weeks. If you are looking for a good back country hunting boot, I feel these might be worth a look for anyone still on their journey for good footwear. I'm sure they may not work for everyone of course, but for me, they are just amazing. Thank you Meindl!
 
#4 ·
I got the Dovres from Europe and found them to be bulletproof. I wore mine on a treacherous rock-on-rock climb above the treeline and they performed perfectly. Hard to brake when you take two steps forward and slide one step back but Meindls perform great in tough terrain. And if a snake strikes he'll bust his fangs off on em. :)
 
#7 · (Edited)
The Meindl for Cabela are wonderful quality. However, the differences that might matter are as follows:

The Meindl made for Cabela is wider, in general, at the toe box (very wide). For the German type, this is called "extra comfort" by way of description. Cabala says to order one full size lower than your norm. Do that.

The sizing from Germany is consistent with UK, with most people saying that by going by either EU numerical, or by the UK fit, Meindl is "true to size."

The Cabelas version is built upon a lower price point so you will find differences in the stitching, leather, lining, rand, insole and shank. The European shanks are all metal, the USA shanks are TPU.

Specifically from the same model from each, the leather from Germany is richer, darker, and is described as "aniline" leather, which has beautiful markings, and is a bit stiffer than the Cabela. This was a positive for me.

Reviewers love the Meindl for Cabela models but love the Meindl models from Germany a bit more because they are "robust" but you pay for that ($100.00+ more). Takes a bit longer to break em in too. Got mine from AJ Brooks in Canada. Because i have very wide dawgs, (most other boots are too narrow for me) the Dovres fit me far better...your mileage may vary. These boots are designed for the most extreme terrain you can travel and probably overkill for most unwilling to tackle the very steep, very wet, very rocky places that eat other boots for lunch. Places like Hawaii's sharp lava rock, granite on granite above the treeline, or my Arctic Circle hunt for muskox.