I had the cottonwood bibs and they are fantastic for the price, I bought them on sale from Rogers for 80$ but I ended up selling it for sitka.
The pullover I would rate as super nice though, the integrated hand pocket in the front is awesome. I bought the sitka fanatic jacket which should've replaced it but I only paid 80 for the pullover too and it's so nice I just can't let it go, I'll probably use it until it hits low 40s with only a base layer than switch over to my other jacket.