Archery Talk Forum banner

Paper vs. vinyl targets?

3.9K views 28 replies 17 participants last post by  capemaybowman  
#1 ·
What are clubs using in your area? Which material do you prefer and why?
 
#2 ·
targets

Our club has been using paper targets glued to carboard for many years and have been fighting the squirrels for as long - as they eat the targets up to get to the glue. We just switched to the water proof plastic targets this year and are really liking them. Squirrels leave them alone and they seem to hold up really well thus saving our club money.
 
#4 ·
I know I've said this a few times before, but I like using latex paint to glue targets. The woodland creatures don't eat it, gives a small degree of water resistance and best of all CHEAP!.

takes a couple of targets to get the just right amount rolled out and the technique of getting the target on with as few wrinkles as possible.
 
#5 ·
The all weather vinyl targets from Maple Leaf are awesome. We've been putting a set on our bales and leaving them out for practice rounds. They can absorb a crazy amount of hits and still be shootable. PLus the rain doesn't effect them at all. We do, however, like to put paper targets mounted on cardboard using latex paint for tournaments though. You get better holes and scoring definition that way, and we were just a little bit scared how the plastic ones were going to do when we made our target order for the year. After shooting both, I would think that the plastic ones would do very well for a tournament.
 
#6 ·
We have been using paper glued to cardboard for years. The squirrels love the wall paper past we use and the targets don't last. We tried the vinyl targets and, while they seemed to last longer, several of the FS people complained of a glare that was produced when the target was hit by the sun at differnt angles.

We have since switched back to paper glued to cardboard using the 3M spray adhesive. We posted targets over a month ago and damage has been minimal. Most of the targets are pristine other than the normal holes and moisture damage.
 
#8 ·
i wonder how the vinyl targets would hold up if they were pasted to cardboard or foamboard too?
 
#12 ·
Question



Why? Why would you want to put them on cardboard when the face will last longer than the cardboard in the rain? Only reason I could see of doing that would be on a really rough butt surface so the face is flat, but even then, you could probably just pull the vinyl tight when you tack them up. They are great faces. The foam board would probably do better, if you had to choose between thew two. But even then, there isn't any way I'm glueing some plastic faces down to anything, too much work for not much gain. After spending some time getting ready for the ohio state championship this weekend in Wilmington, Ohio and painting down a course's worth of field faces onto cardboard backers, the plastic faces are even more appealing!
 
#14 ·
So out of nine field archers, only one has heard of someone having an issue with glare on the target face? Would FS shooters be more vulnerable to glare since they may be using sights with lenses?

Other than a slightly higher cost, this seems to be the only negative to vinyl.

Any other comments or observations about the glare issue?
 
#15 ·
DarkSide shooters are vulnerable to anything real and many things imagined. :wink:
 
#16 ·
well

JRE, JPE, and myself all shoot on the same course. All of our targets are in the shade, so no glare issues there. We all three also shoot FS. I can say that vinyl works very well on our course, but your mileage may vary.
 
#20 ·
Where can you buy the vinyl targets? I had no idea they existed. I obviously haven't used them but for our club, there are very few shooters and the targets are exposed to blowing rain. The paper faces are falling off. This sounds like a great solution for our club at least..
thanks
 
#21 ·
PWArchers has used the vinyl, I shoot FS and had no complaints with them. I havent had time to go to the last shoot but I think we are back to useing paper. I grabed a few of the used vinyl targets and they have been on m y home bale for over three months. They are shot to shizz but I like them.
 
#22 ·
I know this is an old thread but does anyone know where you can purchase the vinyl target faces for a field round I have done searches with no luck
I actually sent an email to maple leaf so hopefully will see if it is their product or not
 
#26 ·
Put a call into them today Cape but they didn't get back to me yet. they did email me a price list but it is just for individual target prices and I would like to just buy a set, if they have a set price I'm yet to know. I will be out of town for a few days so it may be a bit yet before I can talk to them.
 
#28 ·
I like the Mapleleaf vinyl target faces. They cost only a little more ~15-30 cents depending upon size, but last until very shot up. The weather will not ruin them. Some do not like them for tournaments (they are fine with me), but for something left up for practice shooting, I think they are great.