Don't confuse arrow weight and arrow spine. While stiffer spine arrows are normally heavier, there is no direct correlation between the two.
I would get a couple of those arrows weighed either by a pro shop or someone with a grain scale, such as a gun powder scale. If the shaft alone is 7.3 gpi, then it is 182.5 grains. I believe the lightest nock CE makes is 7 grains, the lightest insert is 12. 3 - 4" vanes are about 25 grains. Add your 85 grain tip and I come up with 311.5 grains, which is about 14 grains light. You can either back off your pull to 62# or consider a 100 grain point. Read the rest before deciding.
I checked your bow and shaft specs at Carbon Express' website and the spine is coming out almost perfect. Remember that short shafts have more apparent spine than longer shafts, so shorter shaft arrows must be a lighter spine to achieve the same spine affect. If you change to a 100 grain head you are still 2 draw weight categories below having to jump up to the next higher spine CE shaft. So I would suggest that your shaft is stiff enough.
Since you didn't mention much about the tuning you have tried or not tried, I would suggest checking for any rest contact first, then adjusting your rest to get rid of the left tear, using the 100 grain point. If you can accomplish that without moving the rest more than 1/16" or so from the ideal 13/16" center shot distance, the shaft is the right spine. Also be sure you are not torqueing the bow. I have always maintained, along with many pro coaches, that if the draw length is correct but the string is still slapping your arm on most modern compounds, with the exception of the short brace height speed bows, you are most likely having form problems. These form problems with obviously cause left/right tears.
So I guess, in summary, you should check vane clearance, switch to 100 grain head/points, and tune. A good tuning guide is the Easton guide you can download from their site.
http://www.eastonarchery.com