I have read thru the arguments and the basic idea still is to make sure you have a plan to put into action if you fall. I unfortunately did not have a plan when I fell last rifle season and was hanging there in the pitch black with the bottom portion of my lone wolf laying on the ground below me. Now what????
I did not have my regular screw in step I used to carry in my HSS harness. I was using a regular harness from one of the treestands I bought. So immediately I thought loosen the harness and just slide out, and take the 20' fall. I realized no way as I was trying to figure out what to do to get out. I tried to grab onto the top portion of the climber and pull myself up onto the handclimber but was not strong enough to do that. I then bearhugged the tree pulling myself up just enough to get my harness strap from over the front of the handclimber(strap basically had it locked to the tree). I slid the handclimber down then locked it down, knealt on it, reached up and moved my tree strap down BUT I still had to go back off the handclimber and do the process over again.
This next time was almost my last time going off the handclimber, I hit the tree with the side of my head, as I swung backwards. I was almost out and had to get myself back onto that handclimber. I continued to do this until I was able to get to the ground. Each time I was hanging there I could feel the pressure in my legs.
I sat on the ground completely spent. I had worked all night and went straight out hunting. I was already exhausted when I got there. When I fell it wasn't the treestands fault, it was my stupidity and lack of preperation. BUT I realized that hanging there wasn't going to last long before I was a gonner. I have three young children and a beautiful wife who is my bestfriend waiting for me at home. I have fought and beat cancer and there was noway I was going to die hanging in that tree and leave my family.
The reason I told my story is basically to illustrate that you need a plan. I was lucky I was able to formulate a plan as I hung there. I did not know him personally but the article one of you referenced in Deer and Deer Hunting Magazine was a fellow trooper, who worked within an hour or so of me. He left behind a family and I think that his experience is what stopped me from loosining the harness and trying to slide out. He did so and forgot about the top strap of the harness. We can theorize what happened to him then. I feel that he helped me not make that fatal mistake since there was no top strap to unhook but was rather a sewn in web of straps on the top, where I would have gotten hung up in on my way thru the harness.
After I was on the ground and was thinking straight again, I realized at no time did I remember I had a full backpack on my back. I also had my warm winter coat strapped to the pack, adding a total of 20#'s more to my total weight. See, in the moment we forget about things and react, sometimes for the worse. If I would have had a plan in place, I could have been down the tree and reattached and back up the tree.
Plan, practice, and be safe.
Thanks for your time.
Ray