I dont feel like its silly or out of line. I suppose I would be a bit cautious about someone asking me to send them parts or products with a email. I would imagine if it were you on the other end,with no idea who you were speaking with, you would want some verification that your product failed. They have to stay in business in order to provide continuous customer service.
i asked to do a return, i didnt ask for free product. I think they make a good product; if they had said please take a video and you dont need to return the parts i would have understood more, but thats not what they said. If your gonna spend $300 on something and it doesnt work out of the box thats frustrating. the email response should have been as follows:
Dear Mr. X, We're really sorry you had this problem. Please see attached return label and please reference XYZ for your order. We'll figure out why your light didn't work and send you a new one ASAP. again, sorry for the inconvenience.
now are they gonna figure out why its broken? no, they are gonna throw it away immediately. I fully understand they are a small company and they seem incredibly understaffed, but you dont ask for a video of why your product sucks.
i will admit, if they said "hey, send us a video and we'll get one out tomorrow" that probably would have been an easier concept to understand.
i was more curious if other people had this same issue.