Gordon,
Those stats haven't changed in the 6 years I've been going. Most guys I have been in camp with have a chance at a legal buck, 6 point or bigger in a hunt. Most guys come back year after year, so shooting a 2 year old is not in the plans for most of them. Fred and the rest of the guys will tell you shoot the buck that makes you happy. As long as it has more than 6 points, you're good. I think the bucks taken has increased in the past couple of years, at least for the group of guys I go with. I have been 7 times in 6 years. I've taken 5 bucks 3.5 years of age or older and about 10 does since 2005. I have gone out and seen zero deer during a sit, but I'd be willing to bet you stand a better chance of seeing 12 than 0. Our group of 9 hunters, this past December, brought home 19 deer from a 3 day hunt. Four bucks and the rest does. Are we that lucky? I don't think so, but we are serious and make the most of our opportunities. If that means killing a doe, then so be it. On the hunt I went on in October (just to film for a friend of mine) it was a full moon, the end of a 2 month drought and high temps in the 80's. We still saw over 50 deer and shot 2 does on video in 3 days.
You can shoot up to 2 deer a day in Alabama. If you were to shoot 2 does on a morning hunt, you couldn't go that evening. I usually shoot the first doe I can on a morning hunt, unless a buck is around. Then in the evening I wait for a buck and will only shoot a doe at last light, if I'm sure a buck is not around. You will be amazed when deer come into the green field at 2:30 in the afternoon like they own the place. Bucks walk around alone and in groups just checking things out. It's like no other place I've hunted and I've hunted from Texas to Maryland on a lot of nice tracts of land and this place takes the cake.
Opportunities are what they are, but I'd be willing to bet most folks aren't ready when that time comes and either lie about it or make up excuses as to why they missed. I've got several videos I have shot up on my Youtube channel you can look at, if you want.
http://www.youtube.com/user/pasinthrough?feature=mhum
I have a good reputation and wouldn't be talking up a place if it were less than what I am saying.
The hunting is outstanding and every other aspect is top notch. Great food, skinning shed, cooler / freezer, target range, laundry, food, open bar, did I tell you about the food? Chicken, Pork Chops, BBQ, Catfish and just about anything else you could want (not the place to go if you just started a diet).
Call Nan up and ask for some other references. See what they have to say.
Sorry to go on and on, but sometimes I just can't help myself...