If you don't mind hunting fenced in bulls that may be the way to go but if you want fairchase head to the western states. On these ranches in Sask. if they don't raise them themselves on the ranch they are bought from other elk farms and some are pretty domesticated. If you just want a high percentage hunt that will give you big antlers come to one of these farms but if you want a great hunting experience head west. I would head west.
You want to see how pahtetic some of these farms are. Check out these quotes from one
"Our hunting preserve is located on 200 acres packed with mixed forest. The natural forest setting offers our clients the challenge of "Fair Chase" hunting." I wouldn't call 200 fenced acres fair chase.
They even score then ear tag the bulls as to what score they are. Quote:
"Pick your trophy elk from the specials listed on our website or you can choose any management bull ranging from 275 to 450 plus. All bulls are green scored to SCI requirements in August then colour tagged to their score categories. In your presence your trophy bull will be scored again to verify scores. All scores are unofficial and final at the hunting ranch."
Here is the link to this "great" place.
http://www.abhunting.com/Trophy/ElkMeadows/gallery.asp
CLB