Archery Talk Forum banner

Fleetwood Timberridge a Black Hunter Clone?

2.9K views 7 replies 4 participants last post by  smithca1988  
#1 · (Edited)
I had read that the Timberridge by Fleetwood is a Mandarin Duck Black Hunter clone. Looking at the pictures they definitely look very similar, but I was wondering if anyone knew anything else about them. Trying to figure out why there is a $200 difference between the two.

3 rivers calls the Fleetwood an intermediate bow, but well I prefer it's color to the black hunter, that by itself isn't worth $200.

The Fleetwood looks likes the limbs are cut differently where they connect with the riser(angled vs square ends), which definitely looks cleaner than the black hunter.

3 rivers states riser cut .05 before center vs 1/4 cut past center for the Black hunter.
Brace height of 7.5 to 8.5(per 3 rivers) vs 7.5 to 8 for the Black hunter.

3 rivers and kustomking list the limb materials on the Fleetwood as 'fiberglass and exotic wood' vs 'fiberglass and bamboo' on the hunter. Given I have no idea what 'exotic wood' means that doesn't help, because I could see someone calling bamboo an exotic wood to sound fancy. Fleetwood Riser is 'Maple and exotic wood' vs 'high density technology wood'.
I can't find exact weights to compare.

The black hunter also has a wider limb poundage availability range (30-60 vs 35-55).

So, does anyone have any real, solid info or experience with these two? Does the Fleetwood have a better fit and finish? Same design in better materials? Marketing only?
 
Discussion starter · #2 · (Edited)
So it does appear we have some material differences:

On the page for Western Recreation Industries(company that owns fleetwood), it lists the limbs as maple and fiberglass, and riser as exotic hard woods, zebra wood and maple.

Still interested in hearing if anyone has tried both and can comment on any differences, but based on this, even if the design is the same, the risers are actually real woods vs the high density manufactured wood used in the black hunters.
 
Discussion starter · #6 · (Edited)
Those look really nice, I really like the red and black. Slap a ff flemish twist string done in red and black on there from shatterproof archery, and a fur strike plate and that will be an awesome looking rig.

Edit: confirmed w/ Big Jim comes w/ 57 inch ff string and stick on arrow rest, no string nocks.

But this right here is why I post. Even with looking around those hadn't come up in my search, so thank you for that.
 
Discussion starter · #7 ·
I was told by a local dealer that orders Black Hunters direct from factory that the MK2 model with the square limb butts will save the makers huge amounts of money as they can build and finish one symmetric limb for both top and bottom.

I agree with Dougmax it looks worse than the original.
I get the logic in simplifying production, especially at that price point, and logically I know the shape of where the limb meets the riser won't impact how it shoots, but damn it's ugly that way.
If I wanted to stare at something ugly, I'd buy a mirror.