Archery Talk Forum banner
21 - 40 of 50 Posts
Are you shooting a mechanical broadhead? I find that some heads, especially over the top heads like a a Spitfire makes one heck of a "Twack" when the blades fold back to their deploy position. If using a fixed head you don't get that loud noise and if you get a "Twack" normally means you hit heavy bone.

Glad you found your deer, good job.
 
Sounds to me like 55 yards is beyond your maximum effective range, as with most bowhunters. I have no real advise other than get a dog on the trail. You took a bad shot.

For whitetail, I wouldn't personally shoot past 35 yards and would prefer 25 yards. Whitetail deer can move a mile at that yardage. I shot a broadside buck at 40 yards years ago. He dropped at less than 15 yards traveled. By the time my arrow got to him he had turned 90 degrees to be facing away and the arrow hit inside the leg bone on his right rear quarter and went up into his chest cavity. That was an eye opener and the exact moment I lowered my max shot range to 35 yards.
i shot a buck this year at 48 yards, he was standing on a slight downhill and broadside in the timber. i had a clear shot my moveable sight was set on 45 i aimed a little high knowing the arrow would drop 3 maybe 4 inches. and got him, he went maybe 20 yards and i saw him fall over. i usually practice at 40, 50 and 60 yards often and felt ok about taking the shot. but looking back it was a longer shot then what i would have liked, but im also hunting public land and you dont have a lot of chances of taking a buck.only you know what your limit is.
 
What you can potentially learn from this thread.....

1. Read through the entire thread before responding, as the OP recovered the deer before some folks posted their opinions

2. Don't suggest that 55 yards is too long of a shot on a deer (even though it is most of the time for the vast majority of people), because you will be deemed an "expert" with a tone of derision

3. Since the deer was recovered, the newbie OP posted a photo and a couple more times (but most of the time they never come back to eat some crow if it wasn't). This in response to another current thread concerning folks joining to get advice on a shot....true or not true?

4. If you expect the same results on a 55 yard shot, you too will likely be posting a "can't find my deer" or "what happened?" thread on AT
 
21 - 40 of 50 Posts