Archery Talk Forum banner

PS23 vs Tank 23's

6.3K views 29 replies 28 participants last post by  MisterGrubbs  
#1 ·
Just looking for opinions on which arrow most shooters prefer and why...PS 23's or Tank 23's..(.400)
 
#8 ·
My wife and I both shoot Black Eagles, she usually runs 23's and I usually run 26's. These arrows are some of the truest and most uniform shafts I have ever used. I have broken several of the PS26 shafts but I dont believe there is a shaft on the market that wouldn't have broken under the same circumstances. I dont have a bad think to say about the Tank shafts because I haven't used them, but I do personally really like the Black Eagle products.
 
#9 ·
I shoot the CX Tank 23's, my wife shoots the BE PS23's. Both perform great. I do not think you can go wrong with either. I will say the BE components are a bit to be desired. I do not feel they fit their own shafts well, nor are they very consistent in weight. The BE are better paired with TopHat Components. CX components are much more consistent as well but I still run TopHat with the Tanks as well.
 
#21 ·
I'm going to try 100 in my 23's to start off with. I have some 120's to see which will group better.
 
#24 ·
Just be careful with the Easton SuperDrives!!! A buddy of mine shoots them and loves, found what he thought was a good deal but apparently there is a Easton super drive and and I think it’s called an Easton super drive pro. Only difference is straightness I think one is .001 and the other is .004 or 6 idk. To us we probably wouldn’t see a difference but make sure you get what you pay for. I personally shoot with Ps26


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
#26 ·
Superdrive and Superdrive Pro only relates to the 27 series.
Standard is .005 straightness, Pro is .002.

All of the 23 series are .002.

I shot the Superdrive 23s the past 2 years. I liked them.
Then I tried out the Tank23....put two in a plywood wall, and didn't damage them one bit.
They are buillt like a tank, I know what would've happened if I did that with a SD23.

I've never shot a PS23, but I do like my Tanks. 120 Gr up front, pin bushings and nocks.
They group outstanding out to 50 yards (all I've been able to shoot until now...as the weather is breaking...finally).