
ukey:I shot a nice 10 pointer at 5:30 eastern time this evening. Just wanted to get your thoughts on this one. He was quartered away at 33 yards, had my 30 yard pin on the lower 1/3 right behind the shoulder. Sounded like a good cracking sound.
Cracking sound - hit some solid bone. You want to hear a fa-thump sound.
Right behind the shoulder? Quartered away, that pin should have been further back, unless you mean the pin was centered just behind the exit shoulder. If the deer is hurt bad, they usually head for water. Your deer ran uphill. A mad dash doesn't mean anything. Could have been a death run. But in this instance (tail up) I don't think you hit vitals. Black fir, could have been brisket. remember, there is also a void area above the heart, above the shoulder (just back a touch) that has no vitals or major arteries to catch. Don't think you would have heard a loud crack though. I lost a doe (first one ever) on what I though was a perfect shot. Watched the lighted tip on the arrow go right in. I think I must have hit her too far front in the void. No blood and no arrow after a "pop" sound. (not a thump, and not a crack) Only found 1 speck of blood about 50 yards from impact. Also one thing to consider: Healthy (well fed) deer have a lot of fat. It seals exit wounds even when low, which can seriously delay blood flow, even with a big hole shot downward at 40 degree down angle. (perfect exit hole placement from 15 yards distance) Amazes me... I've seen quartered away liver and one lung shot deer that just didn't bleed for the first 150 yards. (the same one above I was referring to) I knew I had blistered that deer.
Here is a valuable tip for the future: Always aim for where the arrow should come out, not go in. (And remember, the lower hits tends to bleed a lot more, but you're loosing your margin of safety.) I think in the real world of hunting, it's best to put your pin on the deer in a way that the arrow passes right through the center of the vitals. I "think my target as a 3-d round basketball" in the middle of the deer, right in the middle of that ball is where the arrow needs to pass through. This way you have the largest margin of safety. (IMHO) Nor do I believe you want to aim for the heart. Too dangerous, and too close to shoulder / leg. Going for a "perfect heart shot" is outright dumb. What if the dear jumps / leaps instead of ducks? A couple of inches to the side or low, and the shot is junk. (not to mention a "less than perfect shot" which alway seems to happen) The method I use works for me out to ~35 yards with one pin, at a past ~95% success ratio of recovery.
Hope you found that deer!